The honest verdicts · 28 reviews
Board Game Reviews
Independently researched, honestly verdicted — single-game reviews and long-form deep-dives. We find the flaw first, on purpose, then tell you whether it survives play anyway.
Everdell Complete Collection Review: Is the Big Box Worth It in 2026?
Yumi's cozy-but-ruthless buyer's guide to Everdell's giant all-in box: who should buy the Complete Collection, who should start with the base game, which expansion to add first, and how to host the first night so the magic actually lands.
Yumi · 
Kingdom Death: Monster 1.6 Review — Is the $444 Grail Worth It in 2026?
The blunt buyer's verdict on Kingdom Death: Monster 1.6: what the $444 core box actually gives you, who should buy it, who should walk away, and which expansions deserve attention only after the dark has proven you belong.
Dax · 
Bone & Bamboo Mahjong: The 1920s Shanghai Heirloom, Still Hand-Carved Today
A playable family game that doubles as a display piece — why collectors save up for hand-carved bone and bamboo, and how to buy one that's actually in stock.
Yumi · 
Iron Clays: The Luxury Game Currency That Ruined Cardboard Money Forever
A composite-clay, iron-cored heirloom you fund once and pass down — why the Brass crowd treats these as the default upgrade, and how to buy the right set.
Margo · 
Nintendo Daitoryo Hanafuda: Holding Nintendo's 1889 Origin Story in Your Hands
Before the Switch, before the Famicom, there was a Kyoto card-maker pressing flowers onto layered paper. Daitoryo is that company's flagship hanafuda — and the most affordable grail you will ever covet.
Kenji · 
Spirit Island: The Complete Island — Co-op's Crown Jewel, From Spirits to Nature Incarnate
Why the island that taught a genre to think defensively is the keeper's grail — and how to begin building it when half the set has gone hard to find.
Robert · 
Tainted Grail: Kings of Ruin — Awaken Realms' Dark Arthurian Campaign at Full Production Lavishness
A stand-alone, story-soaked heavyweight that represents Awaken Realms at the peak of its craft — and the rare campaign box where the build quality is the story.
Margo · 
The 1849 Staunton in Ebony & Boxwood: The Heirloom Chess Set Collectors Pass Down
A buyable object with a 175-year provenance — genuine ebony, antiqued boxwood, hand-carved knights, and a lineage that outlives the buyer. Here is why connoisseurs save up for the 1849 Cooke pattern, and exactly what to buy.
Robert · 
The Cozy Co-op Grail: Building the Complete Marvel Champions Collection
A living card game you complete without ever gambling on a pack — the warmest co-op shelf in the cards wing, built one beloved hero at a time.
Yumi · 
The Swinging Sticks: The Iron Man Desk Grail That Never Stops Moving
Designed in Germany, hand-built in Thailand, screen-used in Iron Man 2, silent, hypnotic, and impossible to ignore — the one desk object people point at and ask "what IS that?"
Imani · 
Eclipse: Second Dawn for the Galaxy — The 4X Space Epic Worth Clearing the Whole Table For
A full galaxy of exploration, research, conquest, and diplomacy running on a famously elegant action-disc economy — and the version collectors actually hunt. Here's why it's a splurge, and how to buy one without overpaying.
Dax · 
Karakuri Egg Puzzle Box by Akio Kamei: The Japanese Artisan Grail That Collectors Camp For
One hour of pure mechanical poetry. A cherry-wood egg that whispers its secrets if you listen.
Robert · 
Arcs Review: The Trick-Taking Space Opera That Will Either Hook You or Hurt You
Cole Wehrle stuffed a 4X space empire into a 60-card trick-taking game, then handed you the bill emotionally. A verdict-forward deep-dive on why Arcs is brilliant, mean, and not for everyone — and how to lose your first game with dignity.
Dax · 
Ark Nova Review: How a 400-Card Zoo Earned a Permanent Shelf
It nearly didn't make the cut — too long, too heavy, too many cards. Then it became the most-played game on my table. Here's the honest story of how Capstone's heavyweight zoo-builder earned its keep, plus exactly how to not lose your first game.
Robert · 
Cthulhu: Death May Die Review — You Go Insane, Then You Shoot a God in the Face
CMON's two-fisted Lovecraft co-op hands you a fistful of dice and one heretical idea: don't run from the Old Ones — summon them, then kill them. A full guide to the box, the madness mechanic, how to survive your first hunt, and which core to buy.
Imani · 
Earthborne Rangers Review: The Cozy-Ecology Card Adventure Where Nobody Wants to Hurt You
Pull up a chair, friend. Earthborne Rangers is the open-world co-op card game where the wilderness is the welcome, not the war — a plastic-free, compostable box of meadowlarks and slow afternoons. Here is what it feels like to play, how to build your first ranger, and whether it earns the place it'll take on your shelf.
Yumi · 
Frosthaven Review: Is the 25-Pound Colossus Worth $250?
Cephalofair's frostbitten sequel is heavier than a bowling ball, pricier than a console, and more ambitious than anything in the hobby. I dragged it across a campaign so you'd know whether your back — and your wallet — can take it.
Dax · 
Gloomhaven (2nd Edition) Review: Is the Legendary Campaign Worth the Splurge?
A collector's verdict on the grail of campaign board games — what fills the 20-pound box, how the card-driven combat actually plays across 101 scenarios, and whether the $199.99 second edition earns a permanent spot on the shelf.
Robert · 
ISS Vanguard Review: Inside Awaken Realms' Sci-Fi Production Flex
A precise, fact-checked accounting of Awaken Realms' ~$180 sci-fi away-team campaign — the drawer insert, the dual-layer dashboards, the dice-building exploration engine, and whether the lavish production earns its keep.
Margo · 
Nemesis Review: The Alien-in-a-Box Everyone's Obsessed With
Awaken Realms' semi-co-op survival horror is the closest thing tabletop has to your own unscripted Alien movie — paranoia, evolving xenomorphs, and a crewmate who will absolutely lock you in a room with a Breeder. Here's why the community can't shut up about it.
Imani · 
Oathsworn: Into the Deepwood Review — The Premium Storybook Dungeon-Crawler, On the Record
Shadowborne Games' dark-fantasy campaign crawler pairs a novel-length branching storybook with exploding-dice boss fights and 100mm minis. Here's exactly what's in the box, how it plays, whether it's worth the price, and the printing record — footnoted and dated.
Margo · 
SETI: Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence — The Deep-Dive Review
Czech Games Edition's 2024 heavyweight turned a radio-telescope daydream into the most-awarded euro of its year. Here is what the record actually says — receipts, dates, and the myths politely corrected.
Margo · 
Slay the Spire: The Board Game Review — A Faithful Climb That Costs a Fortune and a Table
Contention Games rebuilt the cult roguelike deck-builder in 730 cards and four minis. It's a near-miraculous adaptation with two real problems: it eats your entire table, and at $114.99 it's asking a video game's worth of loyalty before you've drawn a hand.
Dax · 
Sleeping Gods Review: The Cozy-but-Vast Open-World Story Grail
Pour the tea, clear the table, and let me walk you aboard the Manticore. Ryan Laukat's painterly open-world campaign is the rare grail that feels like a warm evening with friends and a vast, breathtaking atlas all at once — here's whether it's worth your ~$100 and your winter.
Yumi · 
Star Wars: Rebellion Review — The Hidden-Base Epic That Earned a Permanent Shelf
A 153-mini galactic war in a box where the Empire is a hammer hunting a needle, and the Rebels win by surviving. I almost left it in the shop over the combat. Here's why it stayed — and how to actually play both sides well.
Robert · 
The Spice Must Flow Again: A Deep-Dive Into Dune: Imperium – Uprising
Dire Wolf rebuilt their deck-builder/worker-placement masterpiece around spies and sandworms, opened the table to six, and quietly made the original optional. Here's how Uprising plays, what's in the box, how to win your first game, and whether you buy this one or the one that started it.
Imani · 
Twilight Imperium: Fourth Edition Review — The Epic Galactic 4X, Examined
Seventeen asymmetric civilizations, a galaxy you build hex by hex, and a single game that swallows a whole day. We trace where Twilight Imperium came from, how a turn actually flows, and whether the eight-hour epic earns its place on your shelf — and in your calendar.
Kenji · 
War of the Ring (Second Edition): A Patient Reckoning With Tolkien's Whole War
Two players. Two ways to win. A single Ring carried east through a continent at war. The definitive grand-strategy duel of Middle-earth, examined slowly and on its own terms.
Kenji · No reviews match that — try a looser search.
More to read in The Reading Room → · or browse all guides →
About our reviews
How does Puzzlewick review games?
Are these reviews sponsored?
What's the difference between a review and a deep-dive?
The fortune-teller's table
Robert has read three for you
“Pull up a chair. The ball's been showing me pieces from the cabinet — three, for you.”— Robert, The Keeper